If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Anyone who owns a copy of the 1988 Breen Encyclopedia no doubt knows how
poorly it was bound, rather surprising and disappointing for a Doubleday product. Essentially you have a paperback glued into a hard cover, and by now the glue has started to dry out and pages are starting to come out quite easily, just like a cheap school tablet. I just engaged a bookbinder to repair my copy. The base charge is $32.00, and I learned that for an extra $20.00, they can sew the body of the book, provide a new pastedown and freefly front and back, and put it right back into the original cover. Since the cover is nicely embossed on the front and goldstamped on the spine, I elected the option. The book cost me $75 when I bought it 20 years ago, so this raises my investment to $127, still only half the cost of buying one on the secondary market, and I get a strong binding to boot. James |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Mr. Jaggers wrote:
Anyone who owns a copy of the 1988 Breen Encyclopedia no doubt knows ... You're still left with a book rife with errors, on average one per page, according to an analysis Alan Herbert did. This is a far higher error rate than is acceptable and a far higher error rate than the vast majority of other nonfiction writers, inside and outside of numismatics, are prone to. Breen was a drug abuser with a faltering memory whose notes were supposedly lost in a fire and a child rapist when he wrote his encyclopedia, and he died about five years afterward in prison, a convicted felon. Yep, this is a book to treasure! Others on Breen: Karl Moulton in a 2001 article in Q. David Bowers' Rare Coin Review: "The time has come for new thinking about much of Walter Breen's research, as he often did not validate his sources or present the facts properly. Many modern researchers are finding substantial credibility gaps in his writings, which cover all areas of American numismatics." R. W. Julian: "That Walter Breen fabricated materials for his encyclopedia and other references is well known. The difficulty is in determining just where this was done." Alan Herbert: "In most cases Breen is no longer the final authority, so use with caution.… He is rightly accused of making up 'facts' to fit his viewpoints…. The problem is picking the good from the bad…. Everything he published is suspect, more or less." -- Consumer: http://rg.ancients.info/guide Connoisseur: http://rg.ancients.info/glom Counterfeit: http://rg.ancients.info/bogos |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Reid Goldsborough wrote:
Mr. Jaggers wrote: Anyone who owns a copy of the 1988 Breen Encyclopedia no doubt knows ... You're still left with a book rife with errors, on average one per page, according to an analysis Alan Herbert did. This is a far higher error rate than is acceptable and a far higher error rate than the vast majority of other nonfiction writers, inside and outside of numismatics, are prone to. Breen was a drug abuser with a faltering memory whose notes were supposedly lost in a fire and a child rapist when he wrote his encyclopedia, and he died about five years afterward in prison, a convicted felon. Yep, this is a book to treasure! Others on Breen: Karl Moulton in a 2001 article in Q. David Bowers' Rare Coin Review: "The time has come for new thinking about much of Walter Breen's research, as he often did not validate his sources or present the facts properly. Many modern researchers are finding substantial credibility gaps in his writings, which cover all areas of American numismatics." R. W. Julian: "That Walter Breen fabricated materials for his encyclopedia and other references is well known. The difficulty is in determining just where this was done." Alan Herbert: "In most cases Breen is no longer the final authority, so use with caution.… He is rightly accused of making up 'facts' to fit his viewpoints…. The problem is picking the good from the bad…. Everything he published is suspect, more or less." If Alan Herbert's analysis is published, I'd appreciate a pointer to the reference if you have it. I'd like to correct my copy of Breen. Thank you. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Reid Goldsborough wrote:
Mr. Jaggers wrote: Anyone who owns a copy of the 1988 Breen Encyclopedia no doubt knows ... You're still left with a book rife with errors, on average one per page, according to an analysis Alan Herbert did. This is a far higher error rate than is acceptable and a far higher error rate than the vast majority of other nonfiction writers, inside and outside of numismatics, are prone to. Breen was a drug abuser with a faltering memory whose notes were supposedly lost in a fire and a child rapist when he wrote his encyclopedia, and he died about five years afterward in prison, a convicted felon. Yep, this is a book to treasure! Others on Breen: Karl Moulton in a 2001 article in Q. David Bowers' Rare Coin Review: "The time has come for new thinking about much of Walter Breen's research, as he often did not validate his sources or present the facts properly. Many modern researchers are finding substantial credibility gaps in his writings, which cover all areas of American numismatics." R. W. Julian: "That Walter Breen fabricated materials for his encyclopedia and other references is well known. The difficulty is in determining just where this was done." Alan Herbert: "In most cases Breen is no longer the final authority, so use with caution.… He is rightly accused of making up 'facts' to fit his viewpoints…. The problem is picking the good from the bad…. Everything he published is suspect, more or less." Aw jeez, Reid, why'd ya have to go and ruin my day? Can't you find it in your heart to say one kind word about the man? Jeez. For the record, the error rate in the new Bowers book on Early American Coins is unacceptably high as well. Drop in on the Yahoo group colonial-numismatics for a peek at all the reported errors. Hopefully Dave will live long enough to come out with a second edition. James |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Thomas A. wrote:
Reid Goldsborough wrote: Mr. Jaggers wrote: Anyone who owns a copy of the 1988 Breen Encyclopedia no doubt knows ... You're still left with a book rife with errors, on average one per page, according to an analysis Alan Herbert did. This is a far higher error rate than is acceptable and a far higher error rate than the vast majority of other nonfiction writers, inside and outside of numismatics, are prone to. Breen was a drug abuser with a faltering memory whose notes were supposedly lost in a fire and a child rapist when he wrote his encyclopedia, and he died about five years afterward in prison, a convicted felon. Yep, this is a book to treasure! Others on Breen: Karl Moulton in a 2001 article in Q. David Bowers' Rare Coin Review: "The time has come for new thinking about much of Walter Breen's research, as he often did not validate his sources or present the facts properly. Many modern researchers are finding substantial credibility gaps in his writings, which cover all areas of American numismatics." R. W. Julian: "That Walter Breen fabricated materials for his encyclopedia and other references is well known. The difficulty is in determining just where this was done." Alan Herbert: "In most cases Breen is no longer the final authority, so use with caution.. He is rightly accused of making up 'facts' to fit his viewpoints.. The problem is picking the good from the bad.. Everything he published is suspect, more or less." If Alan Herbert's analysis is published, I'd appreciate a pointer to the reference if you have it. I'd like to correct my copy of Breen. Thank you. Unfortunately it's typical of the pious cognoscenti to speak in parables and generalities, without furnishing even a single example. James |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Mr. Jaggers wrote:
Unfortunately it's typical of the pious cognoscenti to speak in parables and generalities, without furnishing even a single example. Lots of *individual* examples of errors have been reported since the publication of Breen, reported over the years in this newsgroup and elsewhere. I personally found and reported two of them here, one involving Draped Bust coins, the other Saints, which are the two U.S. coin areas I know best. Others have reported others. To answer Thomas' question, Alan Herbert's analysis from what I understand was from a sampling of pages, not anywhere near the the entire book. Nobody has put together an errata of all known errors because it would be a huge undertaking, requiring hundreds if not thousands of hours hunting down and looking at the original sources Breen supposedly looked at (in many cases he didn't, just said he did, according to those who have looked at individual examples). Also, it would need to be undertaken by someone with a very wide and deep knowledge of U.S. coinage, which few people have. The time required, for any given writer/researcher, would be better spent putting out his own encyclopedia, or so I suspect in trying to put myself in such a person's shoes. -- Consumer: http://rg.ancients.info/guide Connoisseur: http://rg.ancients.info/glom Counterfeit: http://rg.ancients.info/bogos |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Reid Goldsborough wrote:
Mr. Jaggers wrote: Unfortunately it's typical of the pious cognoscenti to speak in parables and generalities, without furnishing even a single example. Lots of *individual* examples of errors have been reported since the publication of Breen, reported over the years in this newsgroup and elsewhere. I personally found and reported two of them here, one involving Draped Bust coins, the other Saints, which are the two U.S. coin areas I know best. Others have reported others. To answer Thomas' question, Alan Herbert's analysis from what I understand was from a sampling of pages, not anywhere near the the entire book. Nobody has put together an errata of all known errors because it would be a huge undertaking, requiring hundreds if not thousands of hours hunting down and looking at the original sources Breen supposedly looked at (in many cases he didn't, just said he did, according to those who have looked at individual examples). Also, it would need to be undertaken by someone with a very wide and deep knowledge of U.S. coinage, which few people have. The time required, for any given writer/researcher, would be better spent putting out his own encyclopedia, or so I suspect in trying to put myself in such a person's shoes. So, am I allowed to feel good again about the money I spent to rebind Breen, or am I just a sentimental old fool? Don't answer that. James |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
You have my permission! One of my favorite numismatic books is
Bowers' book on the Garrett collection. Just because it has lots of mistakes in it doesn't mean I can't enjoy it. On May 9, 5:57*pm, "Mr. Jaggers" lugburzman[at]yahoo[dot]com wrote: So, am I allowed to feel good again about the money I spent to rebind Breen, or am I just a sentimental old fool? *Don't answer that. James |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
Mr. Jaggers wrote:
Reid Goldsborough wrote: Mr. Jaggers wrote: Unfortunately it's typical of the pious cognoscenti to speak in parables and generalities, without furnishing even a single example. Lots of *individual* examples of errors have been reported since the publication of Breen, reported over the years in this newsgroup and elsewhere. I personally found and reported two of them here, one involving Draped Bust coins, the other Saints, which are the two U.S. coin areas I know best. Others have reported others. To answer Thomas' question, Alan Herbert's analysis from what I understand was from a sampling of pages, not anywhere near the the entire book. Nobody has put together an errata of all known errors because it would be a huge undertaking, requiring hundreds if not thousands of hours hunting down and looking at the original sources Breen supposedly looked at (in many cases he didn't, just said he did, according to those who have looked at individual examples). Also, it would need to be undertaken by someone with a very wide and deep knowledge of U.S. coinage, which few people have. The time required, for any given writer/researcher, would be better spent putting out his own encyclopedia, or so I suspect in trying to put myself in such a person's shoes. So, am I allowed to feel good again about the money I spent to rebind Breen, or am I just a sentimental old fool? Don't answer that. James I think it is money well spent. Quite frequently in numismatics errors are found, better dating methods come along (ancient coins) and new historical evidence is uncovered which makes established and respected volumes less than perfect. Part of the charm of numismatics and history may be the reconstruction of it and the slips and turns we make along the way to the truth. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Breen Encyclopedia Binding
bgg wrote:
You have my permission! One of my favorite numismatic books is Bowers' book on the Garrett collection. Just because it has lots of mistakes in it doesn't mean I can't enjoy it. When my copy comes back from the bindery with new life breathed into it, I'll allow it its usual honored spot in the ready-reference part of my library that I keep close at hand! There it will feel back at home again, all cozy among its old friends and neighbors by the hands of Breton, Yeoman, Sheldon, Reinfeld, Brown & Dunn, and Lyman Low. Numismatic bibliomania is good! James |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Source of Breen Encyclopedia and other coin books | Frank Provasek | Coins | 3 | November 3rd 05 08:51 PM |
Encyclopedia of Religion 16 V. Mircea Eliade/New Catholic Encyclopedia, 18 V. | [email protected] | Books | 0 | May 23rd 05 07:12 PM |
Binding Queries | Tom L-M | Books | 2 | May 17th 04 02:28 AM |
variant binding | Fred Baudelaire | Books | 0 | December 16th 03 07:50 AM |
About Breen | Lyntoy1 | Coins | 16 | September 10th 03 02:00 AM |